The race to 'save' our hospitals
Tuesday, April 03, 2007
Labour launches its North Wales manifesto in Old Colwyn today with great fanfare and eleven pledges.
Pledge number one: "Guarantee the future of Llandudno Hospital."
So, is this the end of the long-running saga which has already begun to dominate the campaign in the marginal seat of Aberconwy?
Well, it might be, if it were clear what the pledge actually means. Llandudno hospital has long been earmarked to lose acute medical and coronary care services and in-patient breast surgery services. It is a hospital threatened not, as I understand it, with closure, but with downgrading.
This downgrading is the result of a document called 'Designed for North Wales' which claims to set out the health service framework for the next 20 years. It is a document which, in plenary as recently as 21 March this year, the Health Minister claimed to support:
"The key priorities for North Wales are in line with 'Designed to Deliver', and are the outcome of the document 'Designed for North Wales'. That document proposed a consolidation of mainline hospital services at the three main district general hospitals in north Wales, and at Llandudno General Hospital, along with the provision of new hospitals at Porthmadog and Holywell."
So, one reading of today's pledge might be that it actually backs up what the government has been saying all along. Llandudno hospital may have a future, but there's nothing in Labour's pledge to suggest that future won't be in line with the approved framework; the very same plans which have caused so much unrest.
UPDATE: Health Minister Brian Gibbons has since added that "Plaid Cymru's constant refrain that Llandudno Hospital, the Royal Glamorgan Hospital, Withybush Hospital, Glangwili, Prince Phillip and even Prince Charles hospital are facing closure or downgrading is irresponsible and most importantly completely untrue." I'm sure we'll get further clarification later, but at this moment it seems difficult to marry the position of Brian Gibbons on April 3rd with his position two weeks earlier.
Labels: Aberconwy, Brian Gibbons, Designed for North Wales, Labour, Llandudno hospital, reconfiguration
posted by Blamerbell @ 12:04 am,
,
![]()
It's all white in the assembly
Saturday, March 10, 2007
Lib Dem leader Mike 'German' is about as ethnic as it gets in the Welsh assembly. David Davies is part Hungarian and Bryan Gibbons is an Irishman. Apart from that, Assembly Members are as white and British as they come.(Before Plaid-sympathising readers reach for the diatribe button, be aware: I'm talking census terms here.)
There are often calls to make the assembly more representative. It's already more than half female and attracting an increasing number of young candidates. But when it comes to ethnicity, it's all white.
And so, more or less, is Wales. In the 2001 census, 96% of Welsh people gave their ethnic origin as White British. That's 9% more than in England. Just 1.7% described themselves as members of an ethnic minority group, the largest being Asian/Asian British at 0.9%
But that still means the assembly isn't quite as colourful as it might be. If it were mathematically representative, we'd expect at least one and one fifth assembly member to be from an ethnic minority. Requiring just a teeny swing from the Tories to get a list seat in South Wales East, Plaid's Mohammad Asghar is the ethnic candidate most likely to get elected. If he were to win and then grow an extra leg he'd be perfect for the assembly's sense of balance (though perhaps not his own).
As far as I'm aware, however, there are no ethnic minority candidates contesting guaranteed or near guaranteed seats. It may well be that the assembly goes another four years with Brian Gibbons' brogue as the nearest thing to ethnic diversity. In today's Wales, is that good enough?
Labels: Brian Gibbons, census 2001, David Davies, ethnic candidates, ethnic diversity, Mike German, Mohammad Asghar, politics, Wales, Welsh Assembly Election 2007
posted by Blamerbell @ 10:17 am,
,
![]()
Gibbons: NHS needs more managers
Wednesday, February 21, 2007
What's the best way to deal with the crumbling NHS in Wales? Could it be employing more front-line staff? Supplying more beds? Investing in better equipment and training staff to use it? Providing patients with drugs and treatment they currently have to travel miles to receive?
No. Top of Health Minister Brian Gibbons' wish list is another tier of managers:
"We will be changing the structure of the health service in south-east Wales with more managers being employed and staff being used more effectively.
"Managers are being interviewed this week and we are hoping to get the right people into the right jobs."
Dr Gibbons also warned that it would take time to sort out deep-rooted problems in the NHS. After ten years of Labour government, patients waiting eleven hours in A&E or being driven there in a fire truck may wonder if employing yet more managers is the best solution.
Labels: Brian Gibbons, Health service, management, managers, NHS, Welsh Labour
posted by Blamerbell @ 3:36 pm,
,
![]()
NHS: 'Designed for chaos'
Wednesday, February 07, 2007
Plaid yesterday called for the government's ten year NHS strategy to be scrapped.
They say the forward plan, called 'Designed for life', is unworkable, with 'peasant revolts' emerging all over the country against controversial hospital closures and mergers.
The plan, which is now almost two years old, sets out a ten-year vision for the NHS in Wales. However, it often reads more like a dreamy aspiration than a firm guiding document. For instance, by 2012 "the Health Gain Targets for Wales will be achieved," and by 2015 "Wales will have a world class health and social care service in a healthy, dynamic country."
...And children will dance and sing in the streets while they scatter rose petals in the sunshine.
On the ground, people see only wards closing and cost-cutting. Each 'reform' will be met with fierce opposition and Wales will stutter, not sprint, towards 2015.
The Tories have made the NHS their battleground for the Assembly election. Plaid waded in yesterday. Health Minister Brian Gibbons will be glad he's fighting a safe seat, because in the next few months, he's going to have his hands full.
Labels: Brian Gibbons, Conservative party, Designed for Life, Hospital closures, NHS, Plaid Cymru, Welsh Assembly Election 2007
posted by Blamerbell @ 8:46 am,
,
![]()







